Planning Explorer

Refusal Reasons Page for Planning Application - 12F/3067

Site AddressStarbucks 2 Castle Street Liverpool L2 0NA 

Details

  • Application Number12F/3067
  • Site AddressStarbucks 2 Castle Street Liverpool L2 0NA
  • Property Address2 Castle Street, Liverpool, L2 0TH, Equity And Law House, Castle Street, Liverpool

Reasons 2

The building alterations associated with the proposed change of use to a betting office (Use Class A2), would set an undesirable precedent for the proliferation of further such unsuitable works to listed and historic buildings in this locality, which would further detract from the character and setting of the Castle Street Conservation Area and Liverpool¿s Maritime Mercantile City World Heritage Site.


Reasons 1

The proposed change of use of the vacant ground floor retail unit (Use Class A1) to a betting office (Use Class A2) by virtue of its operations and privacy requirements, which include the installation of window boards and notice displays, will effectively block all glazed shopfronts and stultify associated views into and out of the application premises from both Castle Street and Water Street. The resulting inactive frontages will relate poorly at a human scale, creating the perception of a poorly surveyed and uninviting environment on adjacent streets. Furthermore, the associated external alterations, including the replacement entrance door to Castle Street with asymmetrical arrangement and the satellite dish and air conditioning units to the side roof plane will constitute incongruous, overly prominent and visually harmful building additions. The proposal will therefore detract from the character and appearance of the Grade II listed application building, and undermine the special character and setting of the surrounding historic area, which includes the Grade I listed Town Hall, an identified landmark building within Liverpool¿s World Heritage Site with key views along Castle Street, Duke Street and Water Street, heritage assets of outstanding significance, namely Grade II* listed Martins Bank, listed properties on Castle Street, and the wider Castle Street Conservation Area. As a consequence, the proposal would contravene Policies GEN3, HD4, HD5, HD8, HD11, HD13, HD18, S13, S16 & SPG9 of the adopted Liverpool Unitary Development Plan, Liverpool¿s Maritime Mercantile City World Heritage Site ¿ Supplementary Planning Document and Section 12 of the National Planning Policy Framework.


Other Information Available for Planning Application - 12F/3067